· 3 min read
Protect Donors and Staff Before Giving Tuesday
Giving Tuesday is December 1. Set up email authentication, secure donation accounts, and teach staff to verify payment requests before the campaign emails go out.
Giving Tuesday falls on December 1 this year. Many nonprofits send their year-end appeals in the weeks around it, and scammers send fake charity requests in the same season. Two kinds are worth preparing for: emails that pretend to come from your organization and send donors to a fake donation page, and emails that pretend to come from your director and ask staff to send money or change payment details.
Most of the protection below takes a few hours to set up. Do it before the campaign emails start.
Protect Your Email Domain
Turn on SPF, DKIM, and DMARC: these settings in your domain's DNS tell receiving mail servers which services may send email as your organization. Without them, anyone can send a message that appears to come from your address. Large email providers filter or reject mail that fails these checks, so they also help your real campaign emails reach donors.
Start DMARC in monitoring mode: a policy of "none" sends you reports without blocking anything. Once the reports show that your email system, newsletter tool, and donation platform all pass, move the policy to quarantine.
List every service that sends email for you: your email system, newsletter or donor database, donation platform, and website forms. Each one needs to be listed in your SPF record and set up to sign with DKIM for your domain. Messages from a service that passes neither check for your domain will fail once DMARC is enforced.
Secure the Donation Accounts
Multi-factor authentication: turn it on for email, the donation platform, the payment processor, the website, and social media accounts. A stolen password for any of these can redirect gifts or send fake appeals from a real account.
Old access: check who can log in to the donation platform and payment processor, and remove former staff, volunteers, and vendors before the campaign starts.
Tell Donors What to Expect
One donation address: name the single page where you take gifts and repeat it in every campaign email and post. Donors who know your real address are more likely to notice a fake one.
How you ask for money: if you never ask for gifts by gift card, wire transfer, or cryptocurrency, say so in your campaign emails.
Copies of your page: search your organization's name with the word "donate" before and during the campaign. Report fake pages to the platform hosting them, and warn donors on your own channels.
Train Staff on Payment Requests
Verify by phone: any email or text asking for gift cards, an urgent payment, or a change to a vendor's or employee's bank details gets confirmed by calling the person at a number you already have. A reply to the same message goes to the sender, so it proves nothing.
Refund requests: one known scheme is a large first-time gift followed by a request to refund an "overpayment" to a different account. Refund only to the original payment method, and have a second person approve refunds over a set amount.
One person to tell: staff should know who to contact when a message looks wrong, and that they should report a mistake right away, including their own.
If Something Gets Through
If a donor reports a fake appeal, tell your donors where to give safely and report the fake page. If money went to a scammer, call your bank right away, since transfers can sometimes be stopped when the bank hears about them early. Report the fraud to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and report business email compromise to the FBI at ic3.gov. Change the password on any account that may have been exposed, and check it for forwarding rules you didn't set up, since attackers often add one to keep reading mail.
After Giving Tuesday
Read the DMARC reports for anything sending email as your domain that you don't recognize, and remove any access you gave volunteers or vendors for the campaign.
Sources
- Federal Trade Commission: Cybersecurity for Small Business (opens in a new tab)
- Google (Gmail Help): Email sender guidelines (opens in a new tab)
- FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3): Cyber Criminals Conduct Business Email Compromise through Exploitation of Cloud-Based Email Services, Costing US Businesses More Than $2 Billion (opens in a new tab)
- Nebraska Attorney General: Scammers Targeting Nebraska Nonprofits with Fraudulent Refunds (opens in a new tab)
- Federal Trade Commission (Consumer Advice): Donate to charities (not scammers) on Giving Tuesday (opens in a new tab)
More insights
- Guide2 min read
An AI Use Policy for a Small Nonprofit
Staff are already using AI tools at work. A one-page policy covers which tools are allowed, what stays out of them, and who checks the output.
- Guide2 min read
Before You Fill Out the Cyber Insurance Application
What cyber insurance applications commonly ask small businesses and nonprofits, why accurate answers matter, and how to prepare before renewal.
- Article2 min read
IT Leadership for a Nonprofit Without an IT Department
Many small nonprofits have someone who fixes technology and nobody who runs it. What an IT lead owns, and three ways to get one.
Book a 30-minute call.
Pick a time that works for you, or email or call.