· 3 min read
Questions to Ask Before You Hire an IT Provider
Security and contract questions to ask before hiring an outside IT provider, drawn from CISA, NIST, and other national cybersecurity agencies.
An outside IT provider can run your help desk, install updates, and manage your backups. To do that, it gets administrator access to your systems, so choosing one is a security decision as well as a service decision. Guidance from cybersecurity agencies in the US, the UK, Canada, and Australia points to the same questions. Ask them before you sign, and get the answers into the contract.
Security Questions
Multi-factor authentication: ask whether the provider uses it on every account that reaches your systems. CISA and its partner agencies say contracts should require it on all provider accounts used to access customer environments.
Access: ask what the provider will be able to reach. It should get only the permissions the work needs, through named accounts for each of its staff rather than shared logins. The UK's National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) advises against giving a provider a permanent top-level administrator account.
Security updates: ask how quickly they are installed. The NCSC recommends patching critical or high-risk vulnerabilities within 14 days of an update's release.
Backups: ask how often they run, where they are stored, who can reach them, and how often a restore is tested.
Security logs: ask whether they are kept, for how long, and whether you can see them, and put the retention period you need in the contract.
Incidents: ask how and when the provider will tell you about one. Get the timeframe in writing, and ask which other companies the provider relies on to serve you.
What the Contract Should Say
Who is responsible for what: list the security tasks the provider handles and the ones that stay with you. NIST notes that outsourcing does not transfer your responsibility for protecting your business and your customers' information.
Response times: the NCSC describes under one hour for urgent issues and one business day for minor requests as standard, and notes that faster response usually costs more.
Your data: the contract should say that your organization owns its data, and how it will be returned and deleted when the contract ends.
Regular reports: ask for reports on updates, backup results, and security alerts. The NCSC notes that insurers may ask for recent reports after a claim.
Leaving: write down how access will be handed back and how the provider's accounts will be disabled when the contract ends. CISA notes that disabling those accounts is easy to overlook.
Keep Your Own Keys
Keep a current record of which systems the provider can reach and how. Microsoft recommends two or more emergency administrator accounts that are not tied to any one person, for situations such as the last administrator leaving. Make sure someone at your organization can use them, not only the provider. Ask for documentation of your network, accounts, and devices, and ask for it to be kept up to date.
If you already have a provider, the same questions work as a yearly review of the relationship.
Sources
- National Cyber Security Centre (UK): Choosing a managed service provider (MSP) (opens in a new tab)
- CISA and partner agencies: Protecting Against Cyber Threats to Managed Service Providers and their Customers (AA22-131A) (opens in a new tab)
- National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST): Building Your Small Business's Cybersecurity Team: From In-House to Outsourcing (opens in a new tab)
- Canadian Centre for Cyber Security: Cyber security considerations for consumers of managed services (ITSM.50.030) (opens in a new tab)
- Australian Signals Directorate: How to manage your security when engaging a managed service provider (opens in a new tab)
- Microsoft: Manage emergency access admin accounts - Microsoft Entra ID (opens in a new tab)
More insights
- Template1 min read
AI Use Policy Template for Nonprofits
A free one-page AI use policy template for small nonprofits, covering approved tools, what stays out, review, disclosure, and accounts. Copy and adapt it.
- Guide4 min read
Free and Discounted Software for Nonprofits
How small nonprofits get free and discounted software from TechSoup, Microsoft and Google, what changed in 2025, and what to have ready to apply.
- Guide3 min read
Office Wi-Fi Setup for Small Businesses and Nonprofits
How to set up Wi-Fi for a small office or nonprofit: separate staff and guest networks, WPA3 or WPA2, safer router settings, and better coverage.
Book a 30-minute call.
Pick a time that works for you, or email or call.